High Protein Buffalo Dill Twice Baked Potatoes

The first bake is the part that asks for patience: a russet can look ready on the outside while its center is still firm. I wait until a knife slips easily into the middle, then give the potatoes time to cool enough to handle. That makes scooping much easier and gives the skins a chance to stay sturdy for the second bake.

These high protein buffalo dill twice baked potatoes get their tangy heat from buffalo sauce stirred right into the filling, alongside shredded chicken, cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, and cheddar. The result is hearty without relying on a heavy sauce on top. Fresh dill keeps the filling tasting bright, while the potato skins hold those generous mounds until the cheddar melts and the centers are hot.

High Protein Buffalo Dill Twice Baked Potatoes, golden cheesy tops

“

Kitchen Note

Prick each russet several times before it goes into the oven. That small step gives steam a way out as the skin heats, which helps keep a potato from splitting on the pan.

Save these buffalo dill twice baked potatoes for a filling dinner with tangy heat, tender chicken, and a fresh dill finish.

Save to Pinterest

Why the Buffalo Sauce Belongs in the Filling, Not Just on Top

Buffalo sauce has plenty of punch on its own. When it’s stirred through the mashed potato, chicken, and dairy, that tangy heat gets spread across the whole filling instead of landing in a few sharp spots. Each bite has the same balance, and the potato and creamy ingredients soften the sauce’s edge without hiding it.

That balance matters in a twice-baked potato because the filling is thick and packed into a small space. A drizzle on top would season the surface, but leave the potato and chicken underneath comparatively mild. Mixing the sauce in first gives it room to mingle with the other ingredients before the filling goes back into the skins.

The amount of buffalo sauce also affects more than heat: it brings acidity and moisture along with it. Taste and heat vary a little between brands, so choose a sauce whose spice level you already enjoy. The creamy filling makes it feel more rounded, but it won’t turn a fiery sauce into a mild one.

What the Chicken, Dairy, and Dill Each Bring to the Filling

High Protein Buffalo Dill Twice Baked Potatoes, stuffed russet halves

Russet potatoes — Their fluffy centers mash easily, and the skins make roomy shells for the filling. Choose large potatoes that feel firm and have unbroken skins; smaller or waxier potatoes won’t give you the same amount of fluffy interior and sturdy shell.
Cooked shredded chicken — Mildly seasoned chicken lets the buffalo sauce and dill come through. Leftover cooked chicken works well as long as it’s shredded into bite-size strands; very large pieces make the filling harder to scoop and eat.
Cottage cheese and Greek yogurt — Cottage cheese adds creamy body, while plain Greek yogurt contributes a gentle tang and helps bind the mashed potato and chicken. Full-fat cottage cheese can stand in for low-fat cottage cheese in the same amount, with a richer, slightly heavier result. Keep the yogurt plain and Greek-style; a thinner yogurt can loosen the filling.
Buffalo sauce and cheddar — Buffalo sauce supplies the defining heat and tang, while cheddar melts through the filling and adds savory depth. A familiar, sharp cheddar gives the most noticeable cheese flavor; mild cheddar works too, but the result tastes softer.
Fresh dill — Chopped fresh dill gives the filling a clean, herbal finish that cuts through the creamy ingredients. Use leaves that look bright and perky, and chop them just before mixing so they don’t turn limp or bruised.

From Tender Russets to Hot, Mounded Filling

Bake the potatoes until the centers give easily

Heat the oven to 400°F, prick each scrubbed and dried potato several times with a fork, then rub with olive oil and sprinkle with kosher salt. Set them on a rimmed baking sheet and bake for 50 to 65 minutes. A knife should slide easily into the center; if it catches, the potato needs more time or the scooped flesh will be difficult to mash smoothly. Let the potatoes cool for about 10 minutes, until they’re easy to handle.

Mash and season the filling before stuffing

Cut each potato in half lengthwise and scoop the flesh into a large bowl, leaving about 1/4 inch inside each skin. Mash the potato, then stir in the chicken, cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, buffalo sauce, cheddar, dill, garlic powder, and black pepper. Keep stirring until the ingredients are evenly distributed, so you don’t end up with a pocket of sauce or a clump of seasoning. Spoon the filling back into the skins and mound it as needed.

Bake again until the center is hot

Return the filled skins to the baking sheet and bake at 400°F for 15 to 20 minutes. The tops should look hot and the filling should be heated throughout, reaching 165°F in the center. If the tops look ready before the middle is hot, give them more time rather than pulling them early. Rest the potatoes for 5 minutes before serving so the filling settles slightly.

Three Small Changes for a Different Buffalo-Dill Balance

A Milder Buffalo Filling

Use less buffalo sauce than the full amount for a gentler heat. You’ll also get less of the sauce’s tang, so the finished filling tastes more potato- and cheese-forward.

A Meatless Dill-Cheddar Version

Leave out the chicken and keep the remaining filling ingredients. The potato, dairy, buffalo sauce, and dill still make a satisfying stuffed potato, though it won’t have as much protein or the same hearty texture.

A Richer Cottage Cheese Filling

Use full-fat cottage cheese in place of the low-fat kind, keeping the amount the same. The filling will taste richer and feel a little more substantial, with no change to the baking method.

Storage and Reheating

Refrigerator: Store cooled leftovers in an airtight container for 3 to 4 days. The potato skins soften in storage, but the filling stays creamy.
Freezer: Freeze cooled potatoes individually, then transfer them to an airtight container for up to 2 to 3 months. The texture of the potato may be a little softer after thawing.
Reheating: Warm in a 400°F oven until hot throughout for firmer skins. A microwave is quicker, but it softens the skins; avoid stopping while the center is still cool.

Questions That Come Up When Making Buffalo Dill Potatoes

Can I use rotisserie chicken in the filling?+

Yes. Remove the meat from the bones, shred it, and use it as the cooked chicken in the filling. If it’s strongly seasoned, taste a small bit with the buffalo sauce before mixing in the black pepper.

Can I use dried dill instead of fresh dill?+

Fresh dill gives this filling its bright, leafy note, and dried dill won’t taste quite the same. If fresh dill isn’t available, leave it out rather than adding an uncertain amount of dried herbs; the potatoes will still have buffalo and cheddar flavor, just less herbal freshness.

Can I make these with medium russet potatoes?+

You can, but medium potatoes leave less room for filling and may make smaller portions. Start checking them before the usual baking window, since a smaller potato can become tender sooner; use the knife test rather than relying on time alone.

How do I make a half batch for two people?+

Use two potatoes and halve each filling ingredient. Keep the oven temperature and doneness cues the same; the potatoes still need to become tender in the first bake, and the filled centers still need to heat through in the second.